Spirit’s $10 million data sale: approved from the bench, awaiting the order
After six adjournments, the sale of Spirit’s de-identified enterprise data to Google went to a contested hearing on November 17, 2026, and Judge Sean Lane was widely reported to have approved it from the bench. The unions settled before the hearing through a negotiated sale order; the commercial counterparties did not. As of Friday afternoon, November 20, the signed sale order had not appeared on the docket.
What is being sold, and what is not
At the August 14, 2026 auction, Spirit selected Google LLC as the successful bidder for its de-identified data at $10 million in cash, and Mercor.io Corporation as the alternate bidder at $7.5 million (Dkt. 1463).
The asset is often described as customer data. The Debtors’ filings describe something narrower. In their November 13 omnibus reply, they define the Deidentified Data as Spirit’s own business and operational records and internal communications residing in its remaining enterprise systems, including operational, commercial, maintenance, scheduling and employment-related records and free-form email and chat (Dkt. 1816). The same reply states that the transaction excludes consumer or passenger data and any personally identifiable information, enumerated categories of employee, safety and third-party information, and any data in dedicated systems of record placed entirely out of scope. Anything that does transfer must first pass through an independent de-identification process.
The proposed order carries that limitation into a finding. It would have the court find that the sale is not intended to be a sale of Personal Data, the intellectual property of any Specified Third Party, Excluded Third-Party Data, or information that is confidential under a collective bargaining agreement (Dkt. 1827, proposed order ¶ u).
From auction to hearing
The original sale hearing was set for August 19, five days after the auction. It took three months to reach the courtroom. The Debtors used the time to commission and respond to two reports from the court-appointed consumer privacy ombudsman, and to negotiate first with the unions and then with the commercial counterparties.
The objector map on November 20
The November 17 agenda lists 16 objections and joinders, along with amicus motions and replies (Dkt. 1828). By the hearing, they had sorted into two groups. Organized labor was resolved. The commercial counterparties, whose concern is their own confidential information inside Spirit’s systems, were not. Press accounts of the bench ruling do not say how the court disposed of their objections, and nothing on the docket through November 20 records it.
| Party | Filings | Status as of Nov 20 |
|---|---|---|
| Association of Flight Attendants-CWA | Dkt. 1489, 1656 | Withdrawn Nov 17, effective on entry of the revised order |
| Air Line Pilots Association | Dkt. 1558, 1658 | Withdrawn Nov 16 |
| PAFCA; IAM and TWU Local 570 | Dkt. 1521, 1539 (joinders to AFA) | Resolved or mooted, per Debtors |
| Allied Pilots Association; Airlines for America | Dkt. 1669, 1784 | Confirmed resolved, per Debtors |
| Southwest Airlines Pilots Association | Dkt. 1746 | Resolved or mooted, per Debtors |
| International Aero Engines (IAE LLC and IAE AG) | Dkt. 1538, 1820 | No resolution filed; supplemental objection filed Nov 13 |
| GE Aerospace and CFM International | Dkt. 1810 | Open |
| Navitaire and Amadeus | Dkt. 1602 | Open |
| Springshot, Inc. | Dkt. 1508, 1693 | Open |
| Airbus entities | Dkt. 1819 | No resolution filed; joinder filed Nov 13 |
| EPIC and Professor Seema N. Patel (amici) | Dkt. 1677 | Motion withdrawn Nov 16 |
| SkyWest InFlight Association (amicus) | Dkt. 1774 | No ruling on the docket |
| Joshua Eames-Cepero (amicus) | Dkt. 1783, 1826, 1836 | No ruling on the docket; amended reply Nov 19 |
“No resolution filed” means no withdrawal, resolution or written ruling appears on the docket through November 20; the disposition of these objections at the November 17 hearing will appear in the sale order or the transcript. Statuses marked “per Debtors” rely on the Debtors’ omnibus reply (Dkt. 1816) and were not separately confirmed by the objecting party on the docket. The Debtors also report informal objections from other counterparties and an unfiled pro se objection.
What the unions obtained
The flight attendants’ withdrawal notice is the clearest public summary of the labor settlement, because it recites the provisions of the further revised sale order that the union relied on (Dkt. 1829). The withdrawal is conditional. It takes effect only if the court enters the revised order substantially in the form filed at Dkt. 1827, with changes that do not adversely affect the union or the flight attendants it represents.
| Protection | What the revised order provides | Order ¶ |
|---|---|---|
| Exclusion | Excluded Employee Data and information confidential under a collective bargaining agreement are not sold; Tonic AI, as Deidentification Agent, must remove Excluded Employee Data before delivery | 11 |
| Union search terms | Within 15 days after entry, each union may propose search terms to locate CBA-confidential information; disputed terms may go to the court | 23–25 |
| Re-identification testing | Quantitative assessment of re-identification probability under ISO/IEC 27559, measured against fixed thresholds; no certification until an independent Verification Agent completes its review | 9 |
| Buyer obligations | Google must hold the data in a secure environment, may not knowingly re-identify it (including to profile Spirit employees), and must bind transferees, who are bound by the order as well | 8 |
| Clawback | If excluded union data reaches the buyer, it must use reasonable efforts to prevent public disclosure and delete it; unions may seek emergency relief | 12, 13, 18 |
| Transparency | Within five business days of receiving the exclusion manifest, the Debtors must give each union its portion without request | 27 |
| Lock on procedures | The Data Treatment Procedures may not be changed to the unions’ detriment without a further court order | 6 |
| Alternate bidder | If the Debtors close with Mercor.io instead, the same union protections apply | 37 |
Source: AFA Notice of Withdrawal, Dkt. 1829, summarizing the further revised proposed sale order filed at Dkt. 1827.
The pilots took a shorter route. Their November 16 notice says that ALPA and the Debtors negotiated the terms of the sale and the proposed order, and that ALPA withdrew on the basis of the November 9 revised documents (Dkt. 1824). Those documents included the master de-identification services agreement between Spirit and Tonic AI and a designated recipient agreement between Tonic AI and Google.
Three layers between Spirit’s systems and Google
The Debtors describe the protections as three sequential layers, built in consultation with the objectors and after the ombudsman’s reports (Dkt. 1816 ¶ 8).
The parties adopted the de-identification standard codified under the California Consumer Privacy Act, which the ombudsman, Lucy Thomson, described as up to date. Her supplemental report concluded that “from a privacy perspective, approval of the sale of the deidentified data would be appropriate,” as quoted in the Debtors’ reply.
The vendors’ objection: assurances before delivery
The Debtors and the remaining commercial objectors agree on the premise. Information that a vendor or manufacturer shared with Spirit under a confidentiality agreement is not estate property to sell. The revised order lists 19 Specified Third Parties whose intellectual property and Excluded Third-Party Data are carved out (Dkt. 1827, ¶ 14 and sale agreement definitions). They are Springshot, Airbus, Lufthansa Technik, IAE LLC and IAE AG, RTX, Pratt & Whitney, Hamilton Sundstrand, AerCap Ireland, GE Aerospace, CFM International, Navitaire, Amadeus, Travelir, TravelXchange, Jeppesen ForeFlight, Sabre, Mastercard and Expedia, together with their affiliates.
The dispute is over mechanism. The Debtors rely on third-party search terms applied by Tonic AI before delivery, a court-supervised process for disputed terms, and a post-delivery protocol under which Google, on substantiated written notice, must use reasonable efforts to prevent disclosure of the identified material and delete it (Dkt. 1816 ¶ 3; proposed order ¶¶ 15–16, 18). IAE’s November 13 supplemental objection says the added language and the post-approval search-term protocol do not give it the assurance that all of its proprietary information will be removed before the data reaches Google, and that inconsistencies between the proposed order and the bill of sale create a risk of an authorized transfer of that information (Dkt. 1820).
The GE and CFM objection had narrowed further. According to the Debtors, the Engine OEMs’ only remaining request was that the Verification Agent have aviation and aerospace expertise. The Debtors answered that the Verification Agent reviews a privacy-engineering exercise, and that whether particular information is confidential under a third-party agreement is a legal question reserved to the court (Dkt. 1816 ¶¶ 66–67). They told the court they would continue to negotiate and report at the hearing.
A narrow dispute at the end
Going into the hearing, no remaining objector was disputing the price, the auction process, or the Debtors’ business judgment. The Debtors’ reply notes that no party has raised concerns about how the sale process was run. What remained was a question of proof: whether search terms and a post-delivery deletion right, backed by the court’s retained jurisdiction, adequately protect counterparties whose information may sit in Spirit’s email and operational records.
The pricing-use question
One amicus movant raised a concern that no party in interest had raised: how Google might use Spirit’s fare and booking records. His November 19 amended reply says the revised asset schedule still marks base-fare records, booking curves and competitor-fare observations as included, and asks for a focused explanation of intended commercial uses, citing the 2011 Google and ITA Software consent decree, among other authorities (Dkt. 1836). The amended reply acknowledges that the court, at the November 17 hearing, expressed doubt about whether the proposed statement would assist it and whether the competitive concern warranted further inquiry.
The Debtors’ answer is that the records belong to a carrier that has ceased operations, no longer sets fares, and competes with no one, so a one-time transfer from a carrier in wind-down is not an exchange of information among competitors (Dkt. 1816 ¶ 76).
Where the sale stands
Judge Lane approved the sale from the bench at the November 17 hearing, according to widely circulated Reuters reporting (report). Reuters attributed the approval to the additional privacy protections Google accepted in the preceding week. The docket has not yet caught up. As of Friday afternoon, November 20, Research Suite shows no signed sale order for the de-identified data, and no minute entry or transcript recording the ruling. The amicus movant’s November 19 filing, which refers to the court’s comments at the hearing, is the only post-hearing filing that touches the matter.
The form of the order still matters. The flight attendants’ withdrawal takes effect only if the order entered is substantially the form filed at Dkt. 1827, and the objections of IAE, GE Aerospace and CFM, Navitaire and Amadeus, Springshot and Airbus have no written disposition on the docket. Any changes the court required at the hearing will show up in the order as entered.
Once the order is entered, and if it follows the form filed at Dkt. 1827, several clocks start. Unions would have 15 days to propose search terms. The Debtors would owe each union its portion of the exclusion manifest within five business days of receiving it. And Tonic AI’s certification could not issue until the Verification Agent finished reviewing the re-identification assessment. Closing, and Google’s payment of the $10 million, follow delivery of the certified data.
What to watch
Entry of the signed sale order, any changes from the Dkt. 1827 form, and how it treats the commercial counterparties’ objections. The hearing transcript, once available, will show what the court required. After that come the first search-term disputes, which under the order would return to Judge Lane before any data is delivered.